Ann Mayer, "Islam and Human Rights: New Perspectives in Recent United Nations Discussions"

September 15, 2010Duke Law News

Thursday, September 16, 2010
12:15 - 1:15 pm, Room 3037

Co-sponsored with the Duke Islamic Studies Center

View Webcast



Abstract

In discussions at the UN the Organization of the Islamic Conference (OIC) and its member states have altered the way that they present the relationship between Islam and human rights. For years they followed the route of demanding exceptions to international human rights law based on their need to follow conflicting principles of Islamic law. However, more recently they have decided to change tactics. Instead of appealing to Islamic law to justify noncompliance with human rights, as occurred when many governments claimed that Islamic law precluded their compliance with the Women’s Convention, governments are asserting that they aim to enrich human rights by promoting the values of culture and religion, which are currently often referred to as “traditional values.” They are not alone in this endeavor. Muslim countries joined in support of the 2009 Russian resolution in the UN Human Rights Council on “Promoting human rights and fundamental freedoms through a better understanding of traditional values of humankind,” which is indicative of a current trend to assert that human rights universalism can coexist with cultural particularisms. In practice, the OIC and its members may still aim to exploit culture and religion to curb human rights, but their arguments have been significantly adjusted.
 

Biography

Ann Elizabeth Mayer is an Associate Professor of Legal Studies and Business Ethics at the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania. She earned a PhD in History from the University of Michigan, a Certificate in Islamic and Comparative Law from the School of Oriental and African Studies at the University of London, and a Juris Doctor from the University of Pennsylvania. Her research areas include Islamic law in contemporary Middle Eastern and North African countries and international human rights law, with an emphasis on women's international human rights. She has published extensively, and the fourth edition of her book Islam and Human Rights appeared in 2007.

Other News
  • Remix or Robbery?
    Two copyright scholars present the history of music as an epic battle between creativity and control  
  • Economic Growth and Development in Africa

    Nelly Wamaitha LLM ’17, an attorney from Kenya, describes herself as a skeptic of foreign aid structures and delivery in Africa. “I don’t think Africa’s problems can be solved with some Herculean effort that Africa does on its own, it’s obviously going to be a cooperative effort,” said Wamaitha, who practiced corporate law in Nairobi and London and studied theology at Oxford University before coming to Duke. “That having been said, the world has really botched up Africa in the past.”