Why allowing retail investors into private markets is a “lose-lose” scenario
Duke corporate finance expert Elisabeth de Fontenay says letting Americans invest in private assets will hurt both ordinary savers and the industry
Elisabeth de Fontenay
The recent push to open private markets to retail investors — particularly their retirement savings — has been framed as a way to “democratize” access to alternative asset classes historically reserved for sophisticated institutional investors. Those classes include financial products like private equity investments that fall outside of the highly regulated publicly-traded securities market.
But Duke Law corporate finance expert Elisabeth de Fontenay warns that bringing the estimated $10 trillion in 401(k) retirement assets into the private markets could have dire consequences for the average investor — and for the private markets themselves.
In a new paper, Private Equity for All: The Paradoxical Push to Democratize Private Markets, de Fontenay and co-author William W. Clayton outline the dangers of opening the private markets to retail investors and why the industry has largely kept quiet about the push.
“Behind the scenes, a massive change to both the way we save for retirement and the way we regulate companies in the securities markets has been underway,” said de Fontenay, the Karl W. Leo Distinguished Professor of Law.
“But little attention has been paid to it, and certainly not by the people who ultimately would be affected.”
Different markets, different goals
For decades, the separation of public and private markets has served their respective investor constituencies well, de Fontenay said. Most Americans’ 401(k) retirement accounts are heavily invested in indexed mutual funds and ETFs of publicly-traded stocks and bonds, including target date funds. Public markets are highly regulated; companies must disclose earnings, and trading typically reflects their valuation efficiently and transparently. These accounts are protected by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), which requires plan managers to exercise a fiduciary obligation to participants that includes keeping fees low. Most importantly, the public markets can be indexed, which avoids the longstanding pattern of asset managers draining retail investors’ funds with high fees and poor performance.
In contrast, investors in the private market incur substantially more risk in exchange for the potential for higher returns. Private equity firms purchase faltering companies and attempt to improve their performance before selling them. They also charge high fees, often 2% of the assets under management plus 20% of profits. Unencumbered by regulatory oversight, they can move quickly and efficiently to overhaul firms, creating significant value within the larger real economy, de Fontenay said.
Private funds typically source capital from institutional investors such as pension funds or university endowments and develop longstanding relationships of trust, de Fontenay said. This informal reputational discipline has meant the private markets have been far less litigious; de Fontenay notes an almost complete lack of lawsuits between investors and managers.
But high interest rates and the enormous amount of private capital sloshing around the markets have made it harder to find attractive deals, and, perhaps more urgently, to unload existing companies at profitable valuations, she said. De Fontenay suspects that’s why private equity firms are so keen to tap into retirement accounts, especially target-date retirement funds, where their presence and high fees are less likely to be noticed.
“The confluence of the change in administrations, as well as private equity facing significant liquidity difficulties trying to offload their investments, drove them to change their business model pretty dramatically and start courting retail investors,” de Fontenay said.
A fundamental mismatch
De Fontenay says allowing retirement savers to invest in private markets is a bad idea for several reasons:
- Different liquidity horizons: private equity invests capital by buying companies and selling them years later, meaning investments are locked in. Most retail investors need to access their retirement money within a specific timeframe, and some may need to tap into 401(k)s earlier if they experience job loss or face unexpected medical expenses. Previous attempts to manufacture liquidity for retail investors in private assets have ended badly, mostly recently in the private credit market.
- Private equity funds are actively managed, but have widely variable performance, in contrast to the low-cost index funds in most 401(k) plans, some of which carry no fees.
- Private funds aren't subject to disclosure requirements, making it difficult for 401(k) plan managers and retail investors to assess their true financial picture. Retail investors also won’t be able to access the bespoke terms that large, sophisticated investors negotiate when they invest with private funds.
These and other factors add up to a mismatch between everyday investors and private assets, de Fontenay says, predicting that retail investors will pay higher fees for worse performance, while the private markets will face a wave of litigation and new oversight, hampering their long-term ability to operate freely.
“There will be so much pressure to regulate this market, to require more disclosure, more liquidity, more controls,” de Fontenay said. “Everything that people say they like about the private markets and private capital gets eroded once you change the cast of investors from institutional to retail.”
Clayton and de Fontenay’s private conversations with private-equity insiders suggest that many agree. In their survey of about 70 institutional private-equity investors, nearly every respondent said they expected retailization to damage the private funds industry and predicted that retail investors would suffer the most.
“It's funny how many people have reached out to us and said, ‘I work at a private equity fund, and I think this is a disaster,’” de Fontenay said.
While de Fontenay says private markets play an important role in the economy and are right for those large investors who can absorb the risk, she and Clayton call them something of a “Trojan horse” for retail investors — one that promises higher returns but will ultimately benefit players in the industry positioned to extract fees and manufacture liquidity.
“We were shocked that this seemed poised to sail through without any opposition,” de Fontenay said. “We wanted to at least be on record as saying why we think this is not a good idea.”
“Behind the scenes, a massive change to both the way we save for retirement and the way we regulate companies in the securities markets has been underway. But little attention has been paid to it, and certainly not by the people who ultimately would be affected.”