Professor Francis McGovern had the unusual ability to integrate practical experience, abstract thinking, and teaching. This has earned him the "triple crown" in the legal community as premier practitioner, scholar, and teacher in the field of alternative dispute resolution.
In the late 1970s and early 1980s, Professor McGovern was among the first in the nation to write about and to use alternative dispute resolution (ADR) techniques to avoid or to improve the litigation process. Two decades later, the federal judiciary, many state courts, and institutions around the world, such as the United Nations, all sought his guidance on practical and conceptual issues in dispute resolution. His name is virtually synonymous with "mass claim" litigation--the often tens of thousands of tort claims arising out of a major disaster or major product liability issue.
As a court-appointed special master or neutral expert, he developed solutions in most of the significant mass claim litigation in the U.S., including the DDT toxic exposure litigation in Alabama, the Dalkon-Shield controversy, and his most recent work involving the silicone gel breast implant litigation.
Seeing that these mass claims would take years to reach and proceed through trial at tremendous expense to the parties and courts, Professor McGovern pioneered new roles for court-appointed special masters as "case managers" and "settlement masters." As a case manager, he organizes the pretrial administration of a case, and uses ADR techniques to help the parties agree on efficient discovery approaches and schedules. The role of settlement master has often required that he develop innovative ways to implement potential settlements. In the Dalkon Shield litigation, he helped organize and administer the distribution of the $2.4 billion trust established to compensate 100,000 women who had sued the maker of the device.
To facilitate his efforts, Professor McGovern created very sophisticated computerized models of the valuation of these massive claims. By estimating what the claims are worth to the plaintiffs or will cost the defendants, his models narrow the range of reasonable settlement amounts and help parties to settle more quickly.
Countries outside the United States now are recognizing the effectiveness of Professor McGovern's work. Working with United Nations Compensation Commission, which was set up to ensure that Iraq compensates citizens, businesses and government agencies for losses suffered in the Persian Gulf War, Professor McGovern helped construct a legal framework for handling the 2.6 million claims for reparations from Iraq. He also is developing a transnational ADR center in Europe to handle torts, including silicone gel breast implants and HIV infected blood cases, that cross national boundaries.
A prolific writer, Professor McGovern was the co-author of two published books,Successful Litigation Techniques and The Preparation of a Product Liability Case, and two books in progress, Toxic Substances Litigation and Alternative Dispute Resolution. Both practitioners and scholars rely on his writing for its integration of extensive practical experience with conceptual analysis of fundamental problems in dispute resolution and complex litigation. Professor McGovern's most widely known contribution to the scholarship in this area was his development of the seminal concept of "maturity" in mass torts--a concept generally accepted as critical in analysis of mass torts.
Professor McGovern was widely sought as a teacher, but not only by students enrolled in law school. In addition to carrying a full load of classes, he gave over 50 speeches in the last few years to academics, judges, and lawyers on issues ranging from international dispute resolution to an update of the law of product liability.
Professor McGovern was motivated in all of his undertakings, practical, conceptual and educational, by the public's decreased faith in traditional governmental systems and procedures for resolving disputes. He wanted these systems, like the courts, and procedures, including litigation, to work better. Working better, to him, meant operating both more efficiently and in a manner that leaves participants feeling satisfied about the process and results.
- Mass Torts
- Alternative Dispute Resolution
- Legal Strategy
- Artificial Intelligence & Legal Strategy
- Judges' Seminar
- Products Liability
- Mediating Disasters
- Business Torts
- Dispute Resolution
- Judicial Perspectives on Complex Litigation
Books
- Product Liability Case Digest (2017-2018; 1995- annually updated) (editor with others)
- The Preparation of a Product Liability Case (Little Brown, 1st ed. 1981, 2d ed. 1993, 3d ed. ) (with others)
- Successful Litigation Techniques: Introductory Course Materials (Matthew Bender, ) (with Joseph Kelner)
- Teacher's Guide to Successful Litigation Techniques ()
Articles & Essays
- Trust and the SRBA Mediation, 52 Idaho Law Review 335-340 ()
- Dispute System Design The United Nations Compensation Commission, in War Reparations and the UN Compensation Commission: Designing Compensation After Conflict (Timothy J. Feighery et al eds., )
- The Nez Perce Negotiations, in Through the Waters An Oral History of the Snake River Basin Adjudication 202-224 (Idaho State Bar Water Law Section & Randy Stapilus eds., ) (with others)
- From Charisma to Routine: Presiding over Catastrophe's Aftermath, 29 Negotiation Journal 119-123 () (reviewing Kenneth R. Feinberg, Who Gets What: Fair Compensation After Tragedy and Financial Upheaval (2012))
- Evaluating and Improving the MDL Process, 38 Litigation 26-32 () (with John G. Heyburn II)
- Litigation After "Natural" Disasters, 15 International Liability Forum 13-22 ()
- Punitive Damages and Class Actions, 70 Louisiana Law Review 435-462 ()
- Dispute Systems Design: The United Nations Compensation Commission, 14 Harvard Negotiation Law Review 171-193 ()
- Distribution of Funds in Class Actions - Claims Administration, 35 Journal of Corporation Law 123-133 ()
- La réparation du préjudice de l'Histoire, in Les limites de la réparation du préjudice 209 () (with others)
- Second-Generation Dispute System Design Issues in Managing Settlements, 24 Ohio State Journal on Dispute Resolution 53-79 ()
- A Model Mass Tort: The PPA Experience, 54 Drake Law Review 621-638 () (with others)
- A Model State Mass Tort Settlement Statute, 80 Tulane Law Review 1809-1826 ()
- A Proposed Settlement Rule for Mass Torts, 74 UMKC Law Review 623-636 ()
- Filings By Companies With Asbestos Liabilities, 24 Delaware Lawyer 18-23 (Winter )
- Mediation of the Snake River Basin Adjudication, 42 Idaho Law Review 547-562 ()
- The Evolution of Asbestos Bankruptcy Trust Distribution Plans, 62 N.Y.U. Annual Survey of American Law 163-185 ()
- Compensation Schemes and Dispute Resolution Mechanisms: Beyond the Obvious, 21 Negotiation Journal 231-244 () (with others)
- Common Themes and Unintended Consequences in Class Action Reform, 83 Washington University Law Quarterly 1107-1114 ()
- The Future of Judicial Masters, 31 William Mitchell Law Review 1252-1258 () (2004 Special Masters Conference: Transcript of Proceedings)
- The What and Why of Claims Resolution Facilities, 57 Stanford Law Review 1361-1389 ()
- Judicial Ethics Meet Political Reality, The Bencher (American Inns of Court) (Nov-Dec )
- Asbestos Legislation II: Section 524(g) Without Bankruptcy, 31 Pepperdine Law Review 233-260 ()
- Asbestos Legislation I: A Defined Contribution Plan, 71 University of Tennessee Law Review 155-190 ()
- Mass Torts: Lessons in Competing Strategies and Unintended Consequences, 2 Civil Action 1-2 (Spring )
- Deceptive Trade Practices Litigation: Context and Procedural Standards, in Unfair Competition and Consumer Fraud Statutes 14-31 () (with Sheila L. Birnbaum)
- Litigation as an Alternative to Legislation in Achieving Public Health Reform, 23 La Revue Tocqueville 35-45 ()
- Multiparty Disputes: Managing Variables Key to Successful Arbitration, 9 Dispute Resolution Magazine 3-4 (Fall )
- The Process of Managing Medical Malpractice Cases: The Role of Standard of Care, 37 Wake Forest Law Review 877 () (with others)
- Tragedy of the Asbestos Commons, 88 Virginia Law Review 1721-56 ()
- Foreword: Complex Litigation at the Millennium, 62 Law & Contemporary Problems 1 (Spring/Summer )
- Settlement of Mass Torts In a Federal System, 36 Wake Forest Law Review 871 ()
- Class Actions and Social Issue Torts in the Gulf South, 74 Tulane Law Review 1655 ()
- Toward a Cooperative Strategy for Federal and State Judges in Mass Tort Litigation, 148 University of Pennsylvania Law Review 1867 ()
- Strategic Mediation, 5 Dispute Resolution Magazine 4 (Summer )
- Debate: The Role of ADR in Mass Torts, 53 Dispute Resolution Journal 19-24 (February ) (with others)
- Beyond Efficiency: A Bevy of ADR Jusifications, 3 Dispute Resolution Magazine 12-13 (Summer )
- Judicial Centralization and Devolution in Mass Torts, 95 Michigan Law Review 2077-2089 () (reviewing Michael D. Green, Bendectin and Birth Defects: The Challenges of Mass Toxic Substances Litigation (1996) and Jack B. Weinstein Individual Justice in Mass Tort Litigation: The Effect of Class Actions, Consolidations, and Other Multiparty Devices (1995))
- Rethinking Cooperation Among Judges in Mass Tort Litigation, 44 UCLA Law Review 1851 ()
- The Defensive Use of Federal Class Actions in Mass Torts, 39 Arizona Law Review 595 ()
- Comment: Implementing a Taint Test to Address the Problems Raised by Compelled Disclosure, 59 Law & Contemporary Problems 185 (Summer )
- An Analysis of Mass Torts for Judges, 73 Texas Law Review 1821 ()
- Looking to the Future of Mass Torts: A Comment on Schuck and Siliciano, 80 Cornell Law Review 1022 ()
- The Intellectual Heritage of Claims Processing at the United Nations Compensation Commission, in The United Nations Compensation Commission: Thirteenth Sokol Colloquium (Richard B. Lillich ed., )
- Standing under Section 506 (c) of the Bankruptcy Code Reexamined, 99 Commercial Law Journal 464 () (with Jeremy Galton)
- Introduction: Models for Managing Mass Tort and Insurance Coverage Litigation, in Managing Complex Litigation: Procedures and Strategies for Lawyers and Courts ()
- Lessons from U.S. Alternative Dispute Resolution, in La Médiation: un mode alternatif de résolution des conflits? ()
- Models for Managing Mass Tort and Insurance Coverage Litigation, in Managing Modern Litigation: Learning to Live with New Judicial Controls and New Trial Tools ()
- Foreword: Claims Resolution Facilities and the Mass Settlement of Mass Torts, 53 Law & Contemporary Problems 1 (Autumn )
- The Alabama DDT Settlement Fund, 53 Law & Contemporary Problems 61 (Autumn )
- Resolving Mature Mass Tort Litigation, 69 Boston University Law Review 659-694 ()
- Moving the Pig Through the Python: Multiple Approaches to Resolving Case Management Problems in Toxic Tort Litigation, in Southern Methodist University Products Liability Institute, Personal Injury and Products Liability Symposium ()
- The Discovery Survey, 51 Law & Contemporary Problems 41 (Autumn ) (with E. Allan Lind)
- Court Appointed Experts: An Overview, in ADR and the Courts: A Manual for Judges and Lawyers ()
- Use of Masters and Magistrates in Complex Litigation, in ADR and the Courts: A Manual for Judges and Lawyers ()
- Toward a Functional Approach for Managing Complex Litigation, 53 University of Chicago Law Review 440 ()
- Addressing the Problem: One Court's Strategy, 8 State Court Journal 1 () (with others)
- Management of Multiparty Toxic Tort Litigation: Case Law and Trends Affecting Case Managment, 19 Forum 1 ()
- Managing Complex Litigation: Old and New Devices and Techniques, in Southern Methodist University Products Liability Institute, Evidence and Tactics in the Product Liability Case ()
- Book Review, 4 Environmental Impact Assessment Review 597 () (reviewing James K. Sebenius, Negotiating the Law of the Sea: Lessons in the Art and Science of Reaching Agreement (1984))
- The Organization of Multiple Party Litigation: Class Actions and Multidistrict Litigation, in Southern Methodist University Products Liability Institute, Preparation and Presentation of the Product Liability Case ()
- Toxic Substances Litigation in the Fourth Circuit, 16 University of Richmond Law Review 247 ()
- The Status of Statutes of Limitations and States of Repose in Product Liability Actions: Present and Future, 16 Forum 416 () (reprinted in 1981 Personal Injury Annual 589)
- The Variety, Policy and Constitutionality of Product Liability Statutes of Repose, 30 American University Law Review 579 ()
- The Alabama Extended Manufacturer's Liability Doctrine, in Alabama Pattern Jury Instructions: Civil ()